Dark Energy, Dark Matter(s), Dark Stories

What we are made of and what we make.

Everything that humans have ever touched, built, painted, argued about—our brains, our cathedrals, the iron in our blood, the mRNA vaccines, the stars above—is made of the 5% of the universe that is ordinary atomic matter. That 5% exists within an unseen structure of about 27% dark matter and 68% dark energy. There is a parallel invisible world to this dark sector—the world of stories, myths, laws and speech acts. Both domains hold the universe together and drive its evolution; both require tools to shape the world, and both fall into complete confusion when the line between a measurable physical force and a human construct of meaning blurs.

The Word “Energy”: Cosmological Constants and the Narrative Mind

In physics, energy is not a substance; it’s not a feeling, it’s not some ether or invisible, insubstantial goop. It’s a very precisely defined, conserved quantity. It’s a mathematical quantity: the capacity of a system to do work or transfer heat. It’s measured in joules, and it’s coupled to mass via E = mc². When cosmologists talk about dark energy, they’re not talking about some mystical force or cosmic consciousness. The word “dark” means it’s non-luminous. It doesn’t emit, reflect, or absorb any light. The word “energy” is used because whatever it is that’s causing the universe to expand at an accelerating rate behaves exactly as if it were some form of energy density intrinsic to the vacuum of space itself. It’s often described as Einstein’s cosmological constant (A lambda (or lambda function) is a quick, disposable mini-function that doesn’t need an official name), a form of energy that exerts negative pressure and does work on the spacetime fabric against gravity’s pull.

(E = mc²) means that energy and mass are two different forms of the same thing and can be converted into one another. Because the speed of light (c) is a massive number and it gets squared (c²), even a tiny amount of mass holds an enormous amount of energy.

New Age thinkers, crystal healers, and Reiki people all use the very same term to describe a completely different thing. They draw on ancient vitalist traditions (Chinese Qi, Indian Prana, Greek pneuma, etc.) and use ‘energy’ as a poetic way to describe emotional charge, bodily feeling, concentration, and a general sense of warmth and connection with other people. It’s a rather clever piece of epistemic sleight of hand, really. They take the language of hard science (quantum, frequency, vibration, dark energy, etc.) and use it to lend scientific credibility to their spiritual claims, while throwing out all the empirical rigor that comes with it. If a guru tells you your intention can change the quantum field, the language sounds very scientific, but of course it comes to nothing when you actually look at what’s going on in the lab.

Vitalism is the historical and philosophical tradition holding that living organisms are fundamentally distinct from non-living matter because they are driven by a non-physical vital force, spark, or energy (such as the Greek pneuma, the vis vitalis, or the élan vital).

Sri Sri Ravi Shankar connects ancient Vedantic intuitions with modern science.

None of this means the sensations you experience in energy healing or a spiritual ritual are imaginary. If you’re lying in a quiet, dimly lit room, feeling calmer, warmer, and emotionally lighter as a Reiki practitioner’s hands gently move over you, that is absolutely real. It’s not some imaginary field that you’re being exposed to that’s measurable by a spectrometer or a particle detector. It’s the very real biological effect of ordinary atomic matter. It’s the effect of sensory touch; it’s the effect of lowered cortisol; it’s the effect of slow, rhythmic breathing; it’s the effect of focused human empathy; and it’s the effect of activating the parasympathetic nervous system. To confuse the very real and comforting psychological effects of ritual with fundamental physics is not a higher form of spirituality at all. It’s just a way of closing your eyes to the way nature actually works. As the physicist Richard Feynman so rightly observed in his famous 1974 Caltech commencement address on scientific integrity: “The first principle is that you must not fool yourself and you are the easiest person to fool.”

The parasympathetic nervous system is the part of your body's automatic control network that acts like a brake, helping you rest, digest, and recover after you feel stressed. It maintains daily health and manages everyday housekeeping tasks like repair, waste elimination, and tissue regeneration.

Engineering Silence: How Physicists Hunt Dark Matter Underground

To understand how nature works, irrespective of our own desires, we need tools of staggering precision, and that precision is nowhere more evident than in the global search for dark matter. The modern story of dark matter began in the 1930s with the Swiss astronomer Fritz Zwicky, and it was brought to life in the 1970s by the careful observations of the American astronomer Vera Rubin. Rubin measured the rotational velocities of stars in the outer arms of spiral galaxies, and she expected those outer stars to move very slowly, just as Neptune moves around the Sun far more slowly than Mercury. What she found instead was that the outer stars were whirling around the galactic center at the same speed as the stars closer in to the center. That speed should have been enough to fling the outer stars right out of the galaxy unless some huge halo of invisible matter provided the gravitational glue to hold the galaxy together. “The conclusion is inescapable that non-luminous matter exists beyond the optical galaxy,” she wrote in 1980, later adding with a touch of self-deprecation that “in a spiral galaxy the ratio of dark to light matter is about a factor of ten. That’s probably a good number for the ratio of our ignorance to our knowledge. We’re out of kindergarten, but only in about third grade.”

To get beyond the third grade and actually catch a single particle of that invisible halo, you can’t just look through a telescope. You have to build some of the quietest places on Earth. Take the LUX-ZEPLIN (LZ) experiment, run by an international collaboration of 250 scientists and engineers, located a mile underground in the Black Hills of Lead, South Dakota, at the Sanford Underground Research Facility. The site has a rich human history: it was originally the Homestake Mine from the 1876 gold rush, and in the 1960s, chemist Ray Davis Jr. (of the famous Davis neutrino experiment) used the deep mine to capture neutrinos from the Sun. So you can see what’s possible with human ingenuity: you can take a hole in the ground dug for one thing and turn it into a facility for observing something completely different.

The location of the Sanford Underground Research Facility

On the surface of the Earth, every square centimeter is pummeled by cosmic rays (high-energy protons and nuclei from deep space), which would completely swamp the very faint dark matter signal. LUX-ZEPLIN is buried under nearly a mile of rock, which shields it from the cosmic ray background, reducing it by a factor of millions. The rock itself, however, contains a small amount of natural uranium and thorium. Hence, the engineers have a huge tank of ultra-pure water surrounding the core detector and an outer veto system of gadolinium-loaded liquid scintillator to catch and identify any stray neutrons that might otherwise be misidentified as a dark matter event. At the very heart of this nested system is a titanium vessel containing 10 tonnes of liquid xenon, 7 tonnes of which form the active target.

Cosmic rays are not actual rays or beams of light. They are tiny, high-speed physical particles—mostly individual protons and atomic nuclei—flying through space at nearly the speed of light

When a particle passes through the liquid xenon and hits a xenon atomic nucleus, it produces a two-part signature. The nucleus is knocked off course in the collision and produces an immediate, very small flash of UV scintillation light (the S1 signal) and, at the same time, knocks out a cluster of electrons. A precisely applied electric field then pulls those electrons up through the liquid into a thin layer of xenon gas at the top of the vessel where they are accelerated and produce a much brighter flash of electroluminescent light (the S2 signal). Arrays of extremely sensitive photomultiplier tubes on the top and bottom of the vessel record both flashes in the billionths of a second that they take. The time between S1 and S2, and the ratio of the two signals, can determine the exact 3D position of the interaction and distinguish between a normal gamma ray hitting an electron and a heavy neutral particle hitting a nucleus.

This is a stunning example of the chasm between the scientific notion of proof and the mythic notion of certainty. At the TeV Particle Astrophysics conference in Japan in September 2026, the LZ collaboration presented an analysis of 220 live days of data taken between March 2023 and April 2024 and reported a very interesting high-energy nuclear recoil event which was very much in the expected signature of a WIMP. The signal had a local significance of about 2.6σ (2.6-sigma, i.e., less than a 1-in-200 chance of being due to background). In any theological, divinatory, or New Age context, a 99.5% hint of a force we can’t see would instantly become a sacred text, a dogma, or the basis of a best-selling book. In particle physics, however, 2.6σ is very far short of the 5σ (Five Sigma) gold standard (a 1 in 3.5 million chance of being due to background) required to claim a discovery. As LZ spokesperson and Brown University physicist Rick Gaitskell said when announcing the event, “With just one event, we don’t want to get ahead of ourselves. We’re not claiming to have seen dark matter. We have seen something interesting, and we want to share it with the community for their input.” The fact that thousands of years of theological and metaphysical wrangling are still deadlocked because neither side has an instrument that can prove itself wrong stands in stark contrast to the way experimental physics progresses; it will not believe its own desires until nature forces it to.

A WIMP stands for Weakly Interacting Massive Particle. It is a hypothetical, invisible subatomic particle that scientists believe could make up most of the universe's dark matter

From Firing Neurons to Speech Acts: How Matter Births Stories

If dark matter is the invisible physical scaffolding of galaxies, then stories are the invisible psychological scaffolding of human civilization. Stories have that quality of being weightless, transcendent, and somehow disembodied. We routinely imagine that ideas and spirits exist in some sort of ethereal realm of their own, separate from the physical world. In reality, every story is a strictly material phenomenon. Stories can’t exist without carbon-based brains, without electrochemical synapses firing across neural networks, without the vibration of vocal cords in the air, without mineral pigments pressed onto papyrus, or without electrons moving through the silicon of a server. Matter came first. Consciousness and language evolved from matter’s increasing biological complexity over billions of years: a flabbergasting story, that. If not, what are we talking about?

Yet once biological matter had the capacity for symbolic communication, it could reorganize the physical world. In his seminal 1962 lectures ‘How to Do Things with Words’, the Oxford philosopher J.L. Austin demolished the old idea that language was simply a means of describing the world as true or false. He showed that certain utterances (what he called speech acts) were, in themselves, acts that did things and brought new worlds into being. “In saying what I do I do it,” he said. A judge saying “Guilty,” a shipbuilder breaking a bottle and saying “I christen thee,” and an officiant saying “I now pronounce you man and wife” are all examples of speech acts that don’t simply describe a pre-existing state of affairs. They change the world, the distribution of resources, people’s lives.

We’re hardwired to use this narrative machinery because our brains evolved in a world where social survival was the paramount concern, not intuitive astrology. That’s why we have such a powerful cognitive reflex to anthropomorphize the universe, to see in the wind, the stars, and the misfortunes that befall us, the hand of some lawgiving deity, a jealous creator, some intentional design. For all of human history, we’ve had stories of gods, prophets, ghosts, and aliens of all kinds. None of those stories have any physical evidence behind them. There’s no alien spacecraft in a museum vault, no peer-reviewed materials science paper on the metallurgy of its hull, and no engineering blueprint you could actually reproduce to get through a wormhole. We have all sorts of stories about what God commands or what the energies of the spiritual world do, but we all argue endlessly because every single one of those stories is purely the product of the human imagination in the theater of the mind (the inner world of your thoughts, feelings, awareness, and choices).

Great Nature is sacred and so are our imaginations.

Stories get around the slow processes of analytical reasoning and go straight to the emotional circuit. That’s why the tools of storytelling (language, music, film, architecture, ritual, etc.) are so ethically fraught. In the hands of demagogues, con men and propagandists, they become a very dark art indeed, an art used to generate tribal fear, to extract wealth, to justify war and to enable the accumulation of power on an utterly unaccountable basis. In the same hands, they can generate empathy across great distances, preserve moral memory, create the sublime, and coordinate the efforts of millions of strangers toward a common purpose.

Institutional Facts: Constructing Law, Money, Kingdoms, and Morality

To see how speech acts shape human destiny, look at the bedrock of civilization: law, money, religion, states, kingdoms, and morality. In his seminal 1995 work The Construction of Social Reality (a development of Austin’s theory of speech acts), John Searle made a crucial distinction between ‘brute facts’ and ‘institutional facts’. Brute facts exist completely independently of the human mind. If all human beings disappeared tomorrow, hydrogen fusion in the stars would continue, tectonic plates would still move, and dark matter halos would still hold spinning galaxies together. Institutional facts, on the other hand, exist only through the human mind. If we all vanished tomorrow, the U.S. dollar, the borders of France, the Roman Catholic Church, and the criminal code would all disappear instantly, leaving only inert paper, stone, ink, and e-waste. As Searle put it, human society creates institutional reality through a group’s collective intentionality by asserting that object X counts as status Y in context C. A human being becomes a judge, a metal disc becomes money, a line on a map becomes a sovereign border.

Look at the history of law and kingdoms. c. 1754 BC, King Hammurabi of Babylon had a seven-foot-high stele of black basalt erected, with 282 laws on it covering all the aspects of commerce, property, and punishment. At the top of the stele, the king is carved receiving the symbols of kingship from Shamash, the God of justice. That carving and the accompanying cuneiform text were a monumental speech act in that by claiming to have received the authority directly from the God, the king was able to transform his arbitrary commands into a form of divine law, a form of sacred, unchallengeable cosmic order. A century and a half later, Hume, in his 1741 essay “Of the First Principles of Government,” would lay bare the fundamental paradox of all such regimes. Given that the governed are always in the vast majority of the population, the physical force is always on the side of the governed. Hume therefore observed that kings and states rule not by sheer force of arms alone but by the power of shared opinion, by the shared conventions of legitimacy and right. Modern democracies have replaced the hereditary line of kings with a different, equally potent speech act. The opening words of the American Constitution, “We the People... do ordain and establish,” were a speech act of the highest order, a speech act which created a sovereign nation in the minds of the people. This is precisely what Benedict Anderson later described as an “imagined community,” in which a vast community of millions of strangers, who will never actually meet, can hold in their minds the image of a shared community. Still, as Hobbes observed in Leviathan in 1651, “Covenants without the sword are but words and of no strength to secure a man at all.” The speech acts of law only survive so long as a shared institutional commitment and a commitment to material enforcement underpin them.

The story of money is the story of the narrative’s triumph over the physical. In early Mesopotamian agrarian societies, you’d have clay tablets recording the amount of barley and silver owed. Later, kingdoms issued gold and silver coinage whose value came partly from the ore and partly from the sovereign’s face stamped on the coin. By the 11th century in China, during the Song Dynasty, merchants were so fed up with carrying heavy strings of iron coins that they came up with the jiaozi, the world’s first state-issued paper money. Today, we live in a world where physical coins and notes have effectively disappeared. Modern banknotes and electronic balances have almost zero material value. You can’t eat it, build a house with it, or run a generator on it. Yet the entire global economy runs on the belief that the central bank and the courts will accept the currency as ‘legal tender for all debts, public and private’. That is the real value. That is what gives the paper, crypto keys, and the digital balance their worth.

Religion and morality are equally social technologies which bind people together through sacred narrative and ritual speech. Durkheim’s The Elementary Forms of Religious Life (1912) is the classic study of this phenomenon, in which he demonstrates that moral codes and religious doctrines are ‘social facts’ which exist outside the individual mind and yet which have a powerful coercive and unifying effect on the group. Whether it’s the Ten Commandments, the Buddhist Noble Eightfold Path or the secular human rights declarations of our own time, moral systems take the raw biological impulses of human beings (kinship loyalty, fear of being excluded, the desire for reciprocal altruism) and turn them into enduring principles which enable large numbers of people to co-exist in society without having to go to war with one another all the time. Reciting a creed, taking an oath in court, or singing the national anthem are all examples of ritualized speech that reinforce the neural pathways of trust and obligation, turning a collection of fragile individuals into a coherent social organism.

Reciprocal altruism is an evolutionary biology concept where an organism temporarily reduces its own fitness to help another, with the expectation that the favor will be returned in the future.

I mentioned Prophecy: Prediction, Power and the Fight for the Future (2026) a few essays ago and would like to refer back to it here. Oxford philosopher Carissa Véliz opens with what seems at first a rather pedestrian question in her ‘Overture: What’s in a Prediction?’ and uses it to demolish one of the most enduring of human illusions. We all tend to take predictions, projections and algorithmic risk scores for granted as advance reports on the state of the world, as if the Future were simply a newspaper that had already been printed and was merely awaiting delivery. Véliz argues that this is a complete category error: statements about the Future are never facts. She continues the Aristotelian line of thought with the famous ‘tomorrow’s sea battle’ paradox, which showed that a statement about a future contingent event has no truth value at present, and goes on to state: “Facts belong to the present and the past. An assertion about the Future can be many things: an estimate, a desire, a warning. It can never be a fact. What makes the Future the Future is that it’s not yet here. It hasn’t happened yet. What hasn’t happened doesn’t exist. There are no facts about what doesn’t exist.”

What’s in a Prediction? Epistemology vs. Power

By stripping the predictions of any factual status, Véliz exposes their real function. If a prediction isn’t an empirical measurement of something that’s already there, then what is it when it’s spoken, written in a sacred text, or embedded in a machine learning model? Véliz’s central argument is quite stark: “Predictions are often power moves in disguise of a search for knowledge.” For centuries, priests, astrologers, court seers, financial forecasters, and Silicon Valley types have claimed special insight into the Future to get people to do what they want in the present. Even if the forecaster acts in good faith and makes a prediction they believe is true, the very act of making a public prediction creates new currents of expectation, fear, and incentive.

Crucially, Véliz draws a very clear line between predicting the behavior of inanimate nature and predicting the behavior of human beings. When an astronomer works out the precise trajectory of a comet or the gravitational lensing around a dark matter halo, the cosmos is utterly uninterested in the calculation. Comets and galaxies don’t read the papers; they don’t feel anxious, they don’t change their trajectory to conform to or to defy an equation. Human beings are different. They are self-aware, reactive agents. When an authority makes a pronouncement about what humans will do (whether the ancient oracle of Delphi predicts the fall of an empire or a modern predictive algorithm says a particular citizen is a credit risk or a recidivism risk), that pronouncement actively intervenes in the world. As Véliz points out, “our expectations bend the social world towards our predictions,” and so prophecy becomes “the ground on which fights over the future take place.”

From my vetted Gemini query:

A reactive agent is a simple type of artificial intelligence or automated system that acts purely by reflex—like touching a hot stove and pulling your hand back instantly.

It does not think ahead, remember the past, or make long-term plans. It simply follows a direct “if this, then that” rulebook based on what is happening right in front of it at that exact moment. [1, 2, 3]

How They Work

  1. Sense: They check their environment using a sensor, prompt, or incoming message (e.g., “The room temperature dropped to 60 degrees”).

  2. Match: They look at a pre-set list of rules (“If cold -> turn on heater”).

  3. Act: They execute the action immediately (Turn on heater). [1, 2]

Once the action is done, they forget it ever happened and move on to the next input. [1, 2]

Institutional Facts and Speech Acts

Véliz’s analysis of prediction locks aligns perfectly with the philosophy of institutional facts, speech acts, and reification. In Searle’s terms, the ‘brute facts’ (the mass of an electron, the nuclear recoil of a xenon atom in a deep underground detector, etc.) exist independently of the human mind. In contrast, institutional facts (money, borders, laws, sovereignty, etc.) only exist because humans collectively treat them as real through a series of ongoing speech acts. Véliz’s point is that predictions about human society are themselves future speech acts; they don’t simply describe an objective reality that already exists, but help bring about the institutional facts they predict.

Think about how this dynamic plays out across the very foundations of civilization. In the world of money and markets, a currency or a bank will only survive so long as Hume’s shared ‘opinion’ continues to hold. If a powerful financial prophet says a bank is insolvent or that a currency is going to collapse, that purely non-factual statement will trigger a run on that bank and the bank will go bust as a result. The bank went bust; that’s a fact. In politics and war, if two states each believe war is inevitable, both will go to war in self-defense, each taking the other’s mobilization as evidence of the prophecy, and war breaks out. (Uncle Sam Inc., NATO, Ukraine, Coups, Russia, Invasions, Finance, Arms Sales, Culture, Language, Borders, Resources, Corruption.) In our own age of technology, we see the same thing with the tech prophets who will say a particular path of AI is ‘inevitable’ or who will have an automated system reject you for a loan, parole, or even medical triage based on some statistical profiling. That’s reification as Berger and Luckmann described it: the process by which we take human political decisions and probabilistic guesses and treat them as laws of nature. The mere act of prophecy, in this sense, leads to the surrender of our own moral agency.

The Darwinian Decentering, Cultural Acceleration, and Unchanging Foundations

Step back and look at both cosmic physics and human storytelling, and you see a philosophical revolution of the same order as Darwin’s theory of evolution. Darwin’s 1859 book shattered the comforting notion that we were somehow special, above the natural world. He showed that we were, in fact, part of the same biological continuum as the ape, the bird, and the bacterium. Modern cosmology is the second great decentering. We live on an unremarkable rock in the outer reaches of an unremarkable galaxy. The very atoms that make up our bodies, our oceans, and every visible star are a mere 5% of the universe. The rest of the universe is dark matter and dark energy, and space itself is accelerating. And there is the vacuum of space, and the idea of the Void.

The idea of the void is the concept of absolute nothingness, emptiness, or a vacuum. Across philosophy, science, and Eastern thought, it represents far more than a simple lack of space—it is viewed as a foundational canvas, a necessity for motion, or a state of spiritual freedom. [1, 2, 3, 4]

The Earth is special, and so are you.

There’s a stunning paradox in all of this cosmic humility. From that 5% of ordinary atomic matter we’re made of, billions of years of stellar fusion and biological evolution have produced a three-pound human brain which is sufficiently curious to notice that galaxies out there spin too fast, sufficiently disciplined to bury ten tonnes of liquid xenon under a mountain to test its own theories and sufficiently imaginative to write symphonies and legal codes. As Carl Sagan so beautifully put it in Cosmos, “We are a way for the cosmos to know itself.” The Cosmos has finally opened its eyes through the human nervous system and the scientific instrument (mysticism +).

We’re living in a state of self-awareness within a swirling, chaotic polycrisis of ecological overshoot, nuclear proliferation, AI, and the collapse of institutional trust. On top of that is the sheer speed of cultural change; for most of human history, myths, religious belief systems, and social norms evolved over centuries. Societies had generations to adapt to change. In the age of the algorithmic media ecosystem and generative technologies we now live in, narratives, political identities, and moral panics can be reconfigured in hours. Culture is moving at the speed of light, creating the very real impression that reality is infinitely malleable. If enough people repeat a certain story online, it’s the impression that the physical world will bend to it.

They won’t. Under the frenetic churn of 21st-century culture, the bedrock of reality at every level remains utterly unaltered. At the physical level, the conservation of energy, the radiative properties of greenhouse gases, the biology of pathogens and the gravitational pull of dark matter are all completely blind to our hashtags, our tribal affiliations or our spiritual yearnings. At the human level, our brains are still Palaeolithic organs, desperate for belonging, easily hijacked by fear and utterly reliant on the integrity of speech acts to enable the existence of law, money and peaceful co-existence. Getting through the next few generations is about not conflating the two realms and doing so with wisdom. We have to protect science from the tyranny of magical thinking if we are to measure and manage the material world with any accuracy at all. We have to manage our stories and our speech acts with the utmost moral integrity if we are to have any hope that human civilization is worthy of the universe we have finally started to comprehend.

Find your courage wherever you can and remain curious.

Steven Cleghorn
Steven is an autodidact, skeptic, raconteur and film producer from America who has been traveling since he was a zygote. He's a producer at The Muse Films Ltd. in Hong Kong and a constantly improving (hopefully) Globe Hacker. He's seeks the company of interesting minds.
http://www.globehackers.com
Next
Next

Life, Buried Sunshine on a Finite Planet: The Geochemistry of Oil, the Myth of Endless Supply, and the Human Predicament